The priests and neophytes on Presidio Hill (the first location of Mission San Diego) tried to establish a successful mission at that site, but in 1774, Fr. Jayme recommended that the Mission site be moved inland. The crops were failing, the water was scarce and hard to get, and the soldiers were a bad influence of the Native Americans. Fr. Serra approved the move. The padres and neophytes moved to the present site in August of 1774 and built temporary huts out of wood, tule, manure, and thatch. Eleven adobe structures were built during the first year. Crops were planted, Native Americans from the Nipaguay village were being baptized and everything was going well – until November 5, 1775. In the early morning hours of that day, Fr. Jayme was awakened from his sleep and heard a commotion outside his quarters. Indians were raiding the mission. Approximately 800 Native Americans from the Yuma area, together with several neophytes, looted the church. An open fire erupted, the Kumeyaay went into defensive mode and shot flaming arrows into the buildings, burning the huts down. Instead of running or hiding, Fr. Jayme went out to greet them and with his arms outstretched he said, “Love God, my children”. He was subsequently dragged down to the river and murdered. Because of Fr. Jayme’s self-sacrifice, dedication, faith, and love, he became California’s first Christian martyr. The large white cross out front of the Mission on the east side is dedicated to his memory and is located near the spot where he was martyred. His remains are buried in the sanctuary of the church. Surviving residents of the mission went to the Presidio to live until things settled down and it was safe to return to the Mission.
Written by Msgr. I.B. Eagen, former Pastor of Mission San Diego